Innovation Matrix Assessor
QA Scorecard — 4F Formula assessment with gap analysis and progress tracking
What It Does
Wraps the 4F Formula evaluation engine as a skill with three operating modes. Produces a 6-component QA Scorecard covering dimension scores, triangle balance, gap priorities, endorsement readiness, stage assessment, and action items.
Agent
Dumbledore
Strategic Advisor
Category
Analysis
~5 minutes
Invoke
@innovation-matrix-assessor
Three Operating Modes
Full Assessment
Complete business plan evaluation that produces the full 6-component QA Scorecard. Requires an EvaluationContext with your business overview.
The scorecard includes:
4F Dimension Scores
PMF, FMF, BMF, and Fortune with levels and weights
Impossible Triangle Balance
Detects imbalance when max-min spread exceeds 25 points
Gap Priority Matrix
Gaps sorted by severity x impact for focused improvement
Endorsement Readiness
Per-body readiness percentage: ready, almost, or needs-work
Stage Assessment
Checks if your score meets the threshold for your stage (idea, MVP, revenue, growth)
Top 5 Action Items
Ranked priority actions with dimension and estimated score impact
Quick Check
Focused evaluation of a single BP section. Scores only the sub-dimensions relevant to that section and returns targeted gaps with improvement suggestions.
Progress Track
Compares two evaluation results to show your trajectory. Identifies which dimensions are improving, stable, or declining. A delta of less than 3 points is considered stable.
Stage Thresholds
Your score is evaluated against the minimum expected for your current stage:
| Stage | Minimum Score | What It Means |
|---|---|---|
| Idea | 40 | Early-stage concept with basic validation |
| MVP | 55 | Working product with initial market evidence |
| Revenue | 65 | Generating revenue with growing customer base |
| Growth | 75 | Scaling business with proven traction |
Skill Chain
Based on the assessment results, the skill recommends what to do next:
- If 3 or more critical gaps are found, recommends @bp-reviewer to address writing quality
- If the stage assessment shows you are not on track, recommends @quality-gate to check transition readiness
Tips
- Run Full Assessment after major changes — get a complete picture of your endorsement readiness
- Use Quick Check while editing — validate individual sections as you write them
- Track progress over time — the Progress Track mode shows your improvement trajectory
- Focus on high-impact gaps — the Gap Priority Matrix sorts by severity x impact so you fix what matters most